Harinder Sikka Criticises Meghna Gulzar’s Raazi Adaptation Amid Dhurandhar Buzz

Amid growing buzz around Dhurandhar: The Revenge, author Harinder Sikka has reignited debate by criticising filmmaker Meghna Gulzar over her adaptation of his book.

His remarks have drawn attention as interest in espionage-themed stories rises again.

Criticism of Raazi Adaptation

Sikka’s book Calling Sehmat was adapted into the film Raazi, starring Alia Bhatt.

While the film was widely appreciated both critically and commercially, Sikka expressed dissatisfaction with how his story was translated on screen.

Calls It a ‘Gravest Misjudgment’

In a public statement, the author described choosing Meghna Gulzar as director as his “gravest misjudgment.” He alleged that the film reflected ideological bias and did not fully capture the essence of the original narrative.

He also mentioned that he had received warnings about the collaboration but chose to proceed.

Concerns Over Story Interpretation

Sikka claimed that certain elements of the protagonist’s character and story were altered, which, according to him, diluted the intended message of the book.

Extended Criticism to Other Projects

The author also raised concerns about Meghna Gulzar’s portrayal of historical figures in other films, including her depiction of Sam Manekshaw in Sam Bahadur.

He alleged that certain aspects were omitted or presented from a particular perspective.

Raazi’s Success Despite Criticism

Despite Sikka’s objections, Raazi was a major success and received widespread praise for its storytelling, performances, and direction.

The film remains one of the most recognised espionage dramas in Indian cinema.

Literary Work Continues to Grow

Sikka emphasised that his original work continues to gain readership globally. He also revealed that more of his books are currently being adapted into films and other formats.

Debate Between Authors and Filmmakers

The situation highlights an ongoing debate between authors and filmmakers regarding creative liberties in adaptations.

What Lies Ahead

As discussions around espionage content grow, such debates are likely to continue, especially with increasing cross-platform storytelling.